Hinkley Point: Putting the brakes on could be prudent in light of security concerns over China
As China’s President Xi Jinping arrived on a state visit to the UK last October, the head of an educational charity warned that the British Government should be wary of
hugging a dictator so closely.
Writing on the ConservativeHome website, Nick Timothy, head of the New Schools Network, accused the Government of David Cameron and George Osborne of being so keen to open up the Chinese market for British business, and draw Chinese investment to the UK, that they were not only overlooking China’s dismal record on human rights but were also potentially putting national security at risk.
Of particular concern was the proposed deal that would give Chinese state-owned companies a 33.5 per cent stake in the proposed power station at Hinkley Point, and possibly in two other new nuclear plants. Mr Timothy found it “baffling” that the Government should welcome this when “security experts ... are worried that the Chinese could use their role to build weaknesses into computer systems that will allow them to shut down Britain’s energy production at will.”
Mr Timothy is no longer working in the charitable sector. He is in Downing Street, doing the equivalent job to the one he used to do in the Home Office, as Theresa May’s chief of staff. One Westminster insider once told The Spectator that this man, known as “Theresa’s brain”, influences her thinking “to an almost scary extent”.
Therein could lie a large part of the explanation for the sudden and unexpected decision to put the entire Hinkley Point project on hold, on the very day when the contracts were to be ceremonially signed after the board the French energy firm, EDF, who were to pay two-thirds of the construction costs, had committed themselves to going ahead.
Even if China were not ruled by a secretive dictatorship and were not home of some of the world’s most prolific and skilful computer hackers, there would still be a host of reasons for worrying about whether the Hinkley Point project was worth the risk.
UK news in pictures
UK news in pictures
-
1/35
Newly appointed as manager of the England football team, Sam Allardyce poses for a photograph with an England scarf
Martin Rickett/PA Wire
-
2/35
British Chancellor of the Exchequer Philip Hammond (R), and British Parliamentary Under Secretary of State for Transport and Minister for Aviation, Lord Tariq Ahmad (L), listen to London City Airport CEO Declan Collier, as they pass a British Airways aircraft during a tour of the airport in east London on July 27, 2016. The British government hailed a £344 million investment to expand London City Airport on Wednesday as evidence Britain was "open for business" despite its Brexit vote.
STEFAN ROUSSEAU/AFP/Getty Images
-
3/35
Labour leadership candidate Owen Smith speaks at a rally in London
REUTERS/Neil Hall
-
4/35
Police close a road close to RAF Marham in Norfolk, after a serviceman was threatened with a knife near to the base
Chris Radburn/PA Wire
-
5/35
Tour de France winner Chris Froome celebrates on the podium after the twenty-first and last stage of the Tour de France cycling race in Paris, France
AP Photo/Christophe Ena
-
6/35 19 July 2016
Merlin Entertainment’s Talking Donkeys are put through their paces in preparation for three days of children’s donkey rides, celebrating the start of the summer holidays in London
Mikael Buck
-
7/35 18 July 2016
David Barber, The Queen's Swan Marker, holds a cygnet, or young swan, during Swan Upping, the annual census of the swan population on the River Thames, in a week long exercise where unmarked mute swans are now counted - rather than eaten - in a tradition exercised by the British Crown for nearly 900 years, at Sunbury
REUTERS
-
8/35 18 July 2016
A 'Vote LEAVE' battle bus is re-branded outside the Houses of Parliament in Westminster by the environmental campaign group Greenpeace. The bus which was used during the European Union referendum campaign and had the statement "We send the EU £350 million a week let's fund our NHS instead" along the side was covered with thousands of questions for the new Prime Minister Theresa May and her government about what a 'Brexit' might mean for the environment
Getty Images
-
9/35 17 July 2016
US director Steven Spielberg poses as he arrives to attend the UK premiere of the film "The BFG" in Leicester Square
AFP/Getty Images
-
10/35 16 July 2016
A Raticate, a character from Pokemon Go, a mobile game that has become a global phenomenon, in front of the gates of Downing Street in London
Getty Images
-
11/35 16 July 2016
London landmark, The London Eye is illuminated in blue, white and red lights, resembling the colours of the French flag, as Britons express their solidarity following the deadly attack in the southern French city of Nice A gunman smashed a truck into a crowd of revellers celebrating Bastille Day in the French Riviera city of Nice, killing at least 84 people in what President Francois Hollande on Friday called a "terrorist" attack. / AFP / CHRIS J RATCLIFFE (Photo credit should read CHRIS J RATCLIFFE/AFP/Getty Images)
AFP/Getty Images
-
12/35 15 July 2016
Armed police outside the French Embassy in London, following the death of at least 84 people, including several children, after a terrorist drove a truck through crowds celebrating Bastille Day in Nice
PA
-
13/35 14 July 2016
Foreign Secretary Boris Johnson addresses staff inside the Foreign Office in London
PA
-
14/35 13 July 2016
New British Prime Minister Theresa May speaks to the media outside her official residence 10 Downing Street in London
AP
-
15/35 13 July 2016
David Cameron makes a speech outside 10 Downing Street in London, before leaving for Buckingham Palace for an audience with Queen Elizabeth II to formally resign as Prime Minister
PA
-
16/35 12 July 2016
Former Queen guitarist and campaigner Brian May poses with people dressed as Badgers during a photocall in London. The event was organised to 'urge' the government to abandon their planned Badger Cull which is to be rolled out in the Autumn
Getty Images
-
17/35 11 July 2016
Britain's new Conservative Party leader Theresa May speaks to members of the media at The St Stephen's entrance to the Palace of Westminster in London. Theresa May will become the prime minister who leads Britain's into Brexit talks after her only rival in the race to succeed David Cameron pulled out unexpectedly. May was left as the only contender standing after the withdrawal from the leadership race of Andrea Leadsom, who faced criticism for suggesting she was more qualified to be premier because she had children
AFP/Getty
-
18/35 11 July 2016
Stay Puft Marshmallow Man is seen on the concourse at Waterloo Station in London. Ghostbusters take over Waterloo Station as Stay Puft Marshmallow Man smashes through the concourse during the morning rush-hour
Getty Images for Sony Pictures
-
19/35 10 July 2016
Demonstrators from the Black Lives Matter movement march through central London, during a demonstration against the killing of black men by police in the US
AFP/Getty Images
-
20/35 10 July 2016
Members of the British Royal Air Force Aerobatic Team, the Red Arrows, perform ahead of the British Formula One Grand Prix at Silverstone motor racing circuit in Silverstone
AFP/Getty Images
-
21/35 9 July 2016
Jeremy Corbyn is escorted by police through enthusiastic crowds following his appearance at the 132nd Durham Miners Gala
Getty Images
-
22/35 8 July 2016
To mark exactly one month until Olympic Games and celebrate Usain Bolt’s 9.58 second 100m world record, Virgin Media has created an ambitious installation which transformed the River Thames into a 100m-long video screen, while the Eye itself became a giant stopwatch counting down Bolt’s time. Viewers within the London Eye were able to witness Bolt’s record-breaking speed, thanks to a 100m-long, floating screen stationed on the river beneath
-
23/35 7 July 2016
Home Secretary Theresa May makes a statement outside the Palace of Westminste, after she won 199 votes for the Conservative leadership
PA
-
24/35 6 July 2016
Relatives of military personnel killed during the Iraq War talk at a news conference after listening to Sir John Chilcot present The Iraq Inquiry Report at the Queen Elizabeth II Centre in Westminster
Getty
-
25/35 6 July 2016
Protesters dressed as former British prime minister Tony Blair hold a demonstration outside the Queen Elizabeth II Conference Centre as they wait for the release of the Chilcot Inquiry in London
EPA
-
26/35 6 July 2016
Former Prime Minister Tony Blair responds to the Chilcot report
Getty Images
-
27/35 5 July 2016
Participants march in London as teachers across England stage a 24-hour strike in a long-running dispute with the Government over the "underfunding" of schools
-
28/35 4 July 2016
A remarkable twelve metre sand sculpture has been unveiled on the coast of Cornwall’s Porthminster Beach to celebrate the 10th annual Barefoot Wine Beach Rescue Project globally. In a bid to inspire the nation to keep Britain’s beaches ‘barefoot friendly’, the spectacular artwork has been created as part of the first ever World Beach Rescue Day (WBRD), a global initiative launching on 9 July pioneered by champions of cleaner beaches, Barefoot Wine
-
29/35 3 July 2016
British Conservative party leadership candidate Andrea Leadsom arrives at the BBC television centre in London to appear on "The Andrew Marr Show" in London
AFP/Getty Images
-
30/35 2 July 2016
Tens of thousands of people march through central London in a 'March For Europe Event'. The march is in protest at the result of the EU referendum
Getty Images
-
31/35 1 July 2016
Demonstrators chant as they wave underwear and placards with the words "Liar Liar Pants On Fire" written on them outside the home of former London Mayor Boris Johnson
Getty Images
-
32/35 30 June 2016
Justice Secretary and leading Brexit campaigner Michael Gove leaves his home in Kensington before announcing his intention to run to be the next Conservative Party leader and UK prime minister
Getty Images
-
33/35 29 June 2016
Spectators with umbrellas struggle against strong wind as stormy weather delays play at Wimbledon
REUTERS
-
34/35 28 June 2016
A couple kiss outside the Houses of Parliament during a protest aimed at showing London's solidarity with the European Union following the recent EU referendum
REUTERS
-
35/35 28 June 2016
Queen Elizabeth II & Prince Philip, Duke Of Edinburgh attend the unveiling of the Robert Quigg VC memorial statue in Bushmills village, Northern Ireland
Getty Images
It is a huge undertaking. The scheduled cost is £18bn, and the completion date 2025, but given that so much of the technology is new and complex, no one would be surprised if it ran over budget and late. The risk for EDF, who have to find £12bn of the construction costs, would be immense, which is why the company’s former finance director, Thomas Piquemal, vehemently opposed to the company’s involvement. He resigned in March.
But if it is successfully built, it will be a very nice earner for EDF and its Chinese partners, at the expense of the British public. For 35 years, they would be able to sell electricity to British consumers at a guaranteed price of £92.50 per megawatt hour of electricity, more than twice its present cost. One estimate is that the project could add £230 a year to the average electricity bill.
Read more
Some experts in this field, such as Anurag Gupta, nuclear director at KPMG UK, believe that the way forward is to give up on vast investments and build small modular nuclear reactors (SMRs) such as are already in use in India and Pakistan. He argues: “SMRs are not just seen as a way to provide a reliable, secure, affordable and clean source of energy. It’s hoped that the UK could eventually establish itself as a global centre of manufacturing for this technology, forging a burgeoning national industry that serves the rest of the world and creates thousands of new jobs.”
One political factor that Hinkley Point had going for it was the former Chancellor George Osborne and his penchant for grand projects such as HS2 or the “Northern Powerhouse”. Ed Davey, the Lib Dem who was Energy Secretary in the coalition government was also a convert. Neither Theresa May, nor the newly appointed Secretary of State for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy, Greg Clark, was involved until now.
There are big political risks in delaying or cancelling this project. It threatens relations with China, that vast expanding market, and with France, at the onset of Brexit negotiations that will be difficult enough without getting into a dispute with EDF. But the new Prime Minister and her new Business Secretary evidently decided that being pushed into a decision of this magnitude in their first month in office was the greater risk.
Reuse content